Site Map


2000
» News index 2000

Previous:
25th January 2000
» Prosecution claim damage of £110,000 to HMS Vengeance

Next:
31st January 2000
» Minor Ploughshares Case Still Unresolved After 14 Months

News Index
» 1998
» 1999
» 2001
» 2002
» 2003
» 2004
» 2005
» 2006
» 2007
» 2008
» 2009
» 2010
» 2011
» 2012

Contact details
Trident Ploughshares,
42-46 Bethel St, Norwich NR2 1NR
0845 45 88 366
Email addresses:
» TP
» Media
» Legal Support
» Website


Press Releases & Updates 2000

28th January 2000

Lancaster Judge discharges jury and orders a retrial

Justice Slinger determined that the trial of Rosie James and Rachel Wenham for an indeterminate value of damage to HMS Vengeance (Trident nuclear submarine) could not proceed. This is in response to the last-minute delivery of evidence regarding the value of the damage caused which did not provide the defence with the time necessary to seek an independent assessment.

Having begun the case by delivering a new witness statement claiming a fourfold rise in the value of the damage, for two and a half days the prosecution procrastinated and avoided bringing clear evidence to substantiate their new witness statement. Estimates of the value have ranged from zero to almost one million pounds.

Having been instructed on Thursday afternoon by the Judge to produce the necessary evidence, the trial was halted when it became apparent that the lack of substance and vagueness of prosecution evidence demanded independent assessment. As this would mean a substantial delay, a new jury was deemed necessary.

Vera Baird, Barrister for the defence said

"The sequence of misleading estimates as to the value of the damage leads us to suspect that we cannot rely on a word that is said by Marconi or the Crown."

A spokeswoman from Aldermaston Women Trash Trident said

"With 11 months to prepare for this case, we are surprised that the prosecution presented the court with such dramatic last minute revisions to its evidence. Given the nature and gravity of the legal issues being discussed in this case, we would expect a more professional and serious approach. We stand by our disarmament action but we will challenge unsubstantiated claims made by the prosecution."

A hearing will take place this afternoon at Preston with Judge Opinshaw to determine where and when the retrial will take place.

To offer financial or other support contact awtt@hotmail.com or phone 07808 553778.


 Printer friendly version

Search the Website


 

Trident Ploughshares, 42-46 Bethel St, Norwich NR2 1NR
Tel: 0845 45 88 366
info@tridentploughshares.org